Worth the visit! Nice little place. We picked up a pizza to go but they have several tables available for eat in. The pizza was great! We got the special and thought the crust, the sauce and the toppings were delicious. They have dinners listed on the board and a few of them definitely sound yummy. We will definitely check them out next time (if we can get past the pizza 😄).
I’ve searched for pizza in the upstate for the 6 years, the search is over. The sauce is flavorful the cheese is the correct consistency. The crust… The crust is the best I’ve had in years. The crunch and consistency even when cold are there. Served with paper plates I felt like I was back home in NY. We also ordered garlic knots which were devoured. The owners are engaging and friendly. The shop was clean with ample parking.
Kid-friendliness: Small tables and chairs for kids, free arcade game.
Authentic thin crust, fresh pizza and subs. The staff are extremely welcoming, the facilities are immaculately clean, and the environment is conducive to families with small children.
The aesthetic of the restaurant is very modern with a touch of home. There’s handicapped accessible parking, as well as handicapped-friendly mobility features throughout the restaurant.
The pizza and garlic knots are fantastic. The thin crust is perfectly cooked, and the cheese and sauce are refreshingly light and fresh.
Value is definitely there, as the portions are some of the largest you’ll find in Greer. Conveniently located, with plenty on the menu.
10/10 will be coming back. Pictured: garlic knots, plain cheese and pepperoni pizza.
I got this phenomenal “Anthony’s Special” pizza and these mouthwatering Garlic Knots on a recent visit. This pizza is the BEST pizza I’ve had the pleasure of eating in years!! Everything about it was awesome!! This is the kind of pizza I’ve been longing for!! The Garlic Knots at Anthony’s are amazing!! An order comes with 5 of these delicious beauties and it comes with fresh made, simply fresh tasting tomato sauce!
Anthony’s NY Pizzeria is my GO-TO place for the best pizza!! I strongly encourage you to take a visit to Anthony’s and get yourself some of their absolutely delicious pizza, calzones, strombolis, garlic knots, and more!! This gem is located at 1300 SC-14, Greer, SC. They are open every day of the week from 11am-9pm! They offer dine-in, pick-up, and delivery through your favorite delivery services!! Go get you some awesome pizza!!
If you’re a fan of New York/Jersey style pizza, I highly recommend giving this place a try. We decided to order takeout for family movie night and went with the Emily pizza, a white pie, garlic cheese bread, and some spicy buffalo wings. Everything was cooked perfectly, and even after a 20-minute drive home, the food still tasted amazing. The service and dining area reflect the warm, welcoming atmosphere you’d expect from a family-run business. Definitely worth checking out!
Anthonys New York Pizzeria offers a variety of specialty pizza slices n to choose from. I went with The Margherita and meat lovers. Both were delicious!
The crust was crispy with no flop. The sauce on each were good, the Margherita was my favorite. I liked the cheese on both, and the meatlovers had plenty of toppings. I can’t wait to go back and try some of the other things they have to offer.
Join Our E-mail List for Updates, Specials, and Events!